New Paper: Climate Models Exaggerate Warming In Australia By ‘Almost Double’

  • Date: 23/02/13
  • The Hockey Schtick

A paper published today in the Journal of Geophysical Research finds climate models exaggerate predicted warming of SE Australia from 1960 – 2000 by “almost double the observed magnitude.” The paper corroborates findings of Dr. John Christy that climate models exaggerate warming on a global scale by 1.5 times, and those of Dr. Roy Spencer that the latest climate models warm the tropics 3 times too fast.

A Score Based Method for Assessing the Performance of GCMs: A Case Study of Southeastern Australia

Guobin Fu et al

Abstract
A multi-criteria score-based method is developed to assess General Circulation Model (GCM) performance at the regional scale. Application of the method assessing 25 GCM’s simulations of monthly mean sea level pressure (MSLP) and air temperature, and monthly and annual rainfall over the southeastern Australia region for 1960/1–1999/2000 indicate that GCMs usually simulate monthly temperature better than monthly rainfall and mean sea level pressure. For example, the mean observed annual temperature for the study region is 16.7 °C while the median and mean values of 25 GCMs are 16.8 and 16.9 °C respectively, and 24 GCMs (except BCC:CM1) can reproduce the annual cycle of temperature accurately, with a minimum correlation coefficient of 0.99. In contrast, the mean observed annual rainfall for the study region is 502 mm, whereas the GCM values vary from 195 to 807 mm, and 12 out of 25 GCMs produce a negative correlation coefficient of monthly rainfall annual cycle. However, GCMs overestimate trend magnitude for temperature, but underestimate for rainfall. The observed annual temperature trend is +0.007 °C/yr, while both the median and mean [modeled] values are +0.013 °C/yr, which is almost double the observed magnitude. The observed annual rainfall trend is +0.62 mm/a, while the median and mean values of 25 GCMs are 0.21 and 0.36 mm/a, respectively. This demonstrates the advantages of using multi-criteria to assess GCMs performance. The method developed in this study can easily be extended to different study regions and results can be used for better informed regional climate change impact analysis.

The Hockey Schtick, 22 February 2013