No Tropical ‘Hotspot’ After 17 Years Of Immense CO2 Emissions

  • Date: 22/02/13
  • C3 Headlines

The ultimate test for the IPCC’s catastrophic AGW hypothesis is the existence of the predicted “hotspot” that is a sign of a positive feedback loop for accelerating global warming – newest data show that even after record setting human CO2 emissions the “hotspot” failed to materialize.

(click on image to enlarge – data sources)

Troposphere tropical water vapor feedback hotspot CO2 2012

Per the IPCC’s global warming hypothesis, at the very top of the troposphere, above the equator region, is the location (12km, 200hPa @ 20°N – 20°S) that triggers a positive climate feedback, which produces the mythical runaway, tipping point of accelerated, dangerous global warming, which of course is unequivocal and irrefutable, except when it isn’t.

This location is often referred to as the tropical “hotspot,” supposedly an artifact of modern industrial/consumer human CO2 emissions.

The high climate sensitivity programmed into the IPCC’s climate models is entirely dependent of this hotspot of positive feedback – with the hotspot, climate models predict a scary global warming range that spans from 2°C to 6°C.

If there is no tropical upper troposphere hotspot, then there is no positive feedback, and thus, no climate change crisis as predicted by the IPCC. If there is no hotspot, then the IPCC hypothesis of CO2 caused global warming (AGW) is essentially proven false.

Based on accepted physics, without the positive feedback triggered by the hotspot, surface global temperatures from a doubling of pre-industrial CO2 will increase by some +0.5° to 1.5°C. That is the range climate models predict (depending on the given climate model) if the “hotspot”does not exist.

The IPCC’s gold-standard for upper troposphere data is the UK’s HadAT2 dataset that represents high altitude balloon/radiosonde measurements. These balloons provide a higher resolution of the atmospheric layer temperatures than current satellites can provide. Over time, approximately 28+ million radiosonde measurements have taken place.

A few days ago (2/19/2013), the HadAT2 was finally updated through December 31, 2012 – the previous update of dataset was through 12/31/2011. The above chart plots the latest AT2 dataset and concurrent, well-mixed atmospheric CO2 levels over the last 17 years. (Why 17?)

Conclusions from the chart:

#1.The IPCC’s tropical “hotspot” does not exist.

#2. Atmospheric CO2 levels over 350ppm do not cause a hotspot to occur.

#3. The climate sensitivity to CO2 is lower than expert assumptions.

#4. Temporary natural El Nino events do cause a spike in upper troposphere temperatures but then return to a lower temperature state (no positive feedback loop).

#5. The IPCC, its experts and climate models have been wrong about the mythical hotspot since the UN created the IPCC (1988).

#6. The continuing abysmal failure of climate models is likely associated with the lack of the mythical, hypothesized hotspot.

#7. The AGW hypothesis of tipping point, climate positive feedback is proven false after decades of zero empirical evidence supporting it.

#8. Despite all empirical evidence, IPCC scientists and bureaucrats will keep pushing the hotspot, positive feedback hypothesis in order to continue their lucrative taxpayer funding.

Full story